In March 2020, the week Ontario declared a state of emergency, I published a conversation with Dr. Ann Cavoukian on pandemic #surveillance and what we’d be asked to give up in the name of safety.
Seven weeks later, Sidewalk Labs walked away from Toronto’s waterfront.
Ann had resigned from that project more than a year earlier. We talk about the line she drew there, and why it applies to every “smart” anything being built today.
She served three terms as Ontario’s Information and Privacy Commissioner and created #PrivacyByDesign, which ended up written into the #GDPR and translated into 40 languages. Her core argument is that the trade we keep being sold (privacy or security, privacy or innovation) is a false choice.
Six years on, cameras recognize our faces, the speakers in our kitchens are always listening for a wake word, and #AI models want every scrap of personal data they can get. That makes her argument more inconvenient than ever.
So is she naive? Or are we?





