Although most physicists still consider the paradox unresolved, the paper remains a classic. “That paper is like a Beethoven symphony,” says theoretical physicist Daniel Harlow of MIT. “Most of us would be happy to write one paper that was a tenth as good as that in our whole career.”
The essence of the paper, Harlow says, is best expressed not as a conflict between general relativity and quantum mechanics, but between three principles that physicists hold sacred: unitarity, locality, and the validity of statistical mechanics. The unitarity of quantum mechanics forbids information loss, locality means that nothing inside the event horizon can influence anything outside, and statistical mechanics dictates the relationship between black hole entropy and surface area. In effect, Hawking showed that not all these three things can be true. But which one gives way? That’s the consideration behind all efforts to resolve the information paradox today—and there’s still no consensus about the answer.
“What was so valuable about the 1976 paper was that it led to this amazing discussion that went on for 50 years,” Carr says. “There are all sorts of theoretical developments that have come out of the information paradox. So some people would argue that Hawking’s 1976 paper was in a certain sense even more valuable and productive than the 1974 paper.” He adds, “I think that the resolution of [the paradox] will really only come with the final theory of physics,” meaning a quantum theory of gravity.