|
| |
PROFESSOR DONALD W. BRABEN
The February 23, 2008
NewScientist article
Why peer review thwarts innovation said
ONCE upon a time, economists thought economic growth came from the holy
trinity of capital, resources and labor. Then in the 1950s, the
American economist Robert Solow proved that this accounted for only
around 10 per cent. The remaining 90 per cent he put down to "technical
change" technological progress and growth in knowledge. Science
and
technology, in other words. In 1987, he won the Nobel prize in economics
for his discovery.
Today we seem to have forgotten Solow's insight. The key to scientific
and technological productivity is to give creativity full rein. The
academic research that spawned almost all the major advances of the 20th
century, and which in turn fuelled spectacular global economic growth,
was largely unmanaged. Yet in the 1970s, things changed. Since then,
scientists have had to aim their funding proposals at specific
objectives. Peer review, seen as fundamental to scientific progress by
too many researchers, has removed all spontaneity from the process of
generating ideas. Such policies have led to a glittering profusion of
new technologies, but most of them stem from major discoveries made
decades ago. We are living off the seed corn.
Donald W. Braben, Ph.D., FIoP was the author of this article and is
author of
Scientific Freedom: The Elixir of Civilization and
Pioneering Research: A Risk Worth Taking. He is also
Visiting Professor, Department of Earth Sciences, University College
London.
Don spent some sixteen-years in nuclear structure and high-energy
physics
research. That was followed by senior positions at the Cabinet Office in
Whitehall, the Science Research Council in London, and the Bank of
England. He is the author of many papers on nuclear and
elementary-particle physics, and
on science policy. He has appeared many times on
national radio and television and was
the main participant in a one-hour Channel 4 television programme
"Blue Skies" dedicated to the
Venture Research initiative, and
broadcast
(1990) in the Equinox series.
He authored
UK science must not roll over and play dead,
Innovation and academic research,
Bucking the trends,
Blue Skies Research and the global economy,
Exploring the Future: Trends and Discontinuities,
Promoting Innovation in a Bureaucratic World, and
Review: Whatever happened to Pandora's last gift?
Don earned his BSc (Honors) in Physics at the University of Liverpool in
1957 and his PhD in Nuclear
Physics at the University of Liverpool in 1961. He was elected a Fellow
of the Institute Of Physics in 1974. And received an Honorary
Fellowship from University of
Manchester Institute of Science
and Technology in 1989.
Listen to him and fellow SAB member
Colin Blakemore
on the BBC Radio 4 program
Blue Skies Research.
Read
Today, we'd ignore Einstein and
A dangerous experiment.
Explore
The Blue Skies Research Web Site.
Print bio!
|
|