At Lifeboat Foundation, we read every letter received and respond to as
many as possible! But there are too many letters for our staff to
conceivably answer every individual query. So, since many of the
following questions have not been covered in our general FAQ, we decided
to create a forum for the overflow.
Print page!
Assuming
the "grey goo" scenario is inevitable, how do you know that
someone won't bring a stray replicator on a space colony just before
they
start devouring the earth?
On its own, grey goo could not escape Earth's gravity field, so in that
respect a space colony would be safer. However, strict security measures
to check people for nano-built weapons and self-replicators before they
board space colonies would be essential.
By the way, this is a good reason to launch lifeboats as early as
possible. It would be easier to search a person for grey goo than to
search a biosphere but easier is not the same as easy!
How do you
know a nanobot won't escape into space and devour a
space colony?
Grey goo would not have the ability to launch itself into space. In
theory, a meteor strike could blast goo into space Mars rocks have
been
found on Earth. For a variety of reasons, it would be best if the space
colonies were placed as far away from Earth as possible.
Is it really inevitable? Nanobots need some kind of fuel.
Life has covered the Earth (including the atmosphere and lithosphere)
simply by using available "fuel sources". Nanotechnology-based machines
could do the same.
Why build a replicator if its only function is to build more
replicators? How will that help anyone do anything?
We have to worry about hobbyists building useless goo just
because they can. We also need
to worry about destructive scenarios such
as nano-fueled arms races and war.
According to a NASA study, a colony needs a population in the hundreds
of thousands to support any kind of industry. How could we get that
many people to live in a space colony? It would be very
expensive.
This study must have been based on out-of-date technology. In theory, all
that is required is human stem cells and robots to create the human
colony at the desired destination (such a method could be used for
interstellar space travel, for example). Our plans for space colonies,
however, contain 1,000 fully developed humans.
|
|