The article A Risk to Earth said
An upcoming physics experiment may destroy the earth. Recent developments in physics suggest that the next generation of heavy ion colliders may create mini black holes. (A large collider that will be thirty times more powerful than current models is under construction at CERN.) It is thought that mini black holes will dissipate via Hawking radiation. But Hawking radiation has never been seen nor tested. If Hawking radiation does not work, a mini black hole could swallow the earth.
This risk seems a classic case for being careful, for what risk analysts call "the precautionary principle". Unfortunately it appears that this principle is not yet being applied. A Cassandra complex is at work. Cassandra predicted the fall of her city, Troy, but was not heard. The same is happening with this issue. The public is apathetic. CERN physicists are good enough people, but it is hard to cancel a multibillion dollar project because of low-probability concerns. Physicists have been cautioned for discussing the issue. The product of CERN's own risk assessment, drafted eight months ago, is not yet released. Francesco Calogero, a physicist, has suggested that the risks be evaluated by a red team, arguing in favor, and a blue team, arguing against. It is up to us, the public, to provide the blue team.
James Blodgett, M.A. (sociology), M.B.A., M.S. (statistics),
was the author of this article and
is
coordinator of the
American Mensa Global Risk Reduction Special
Interest
Group. He is contact person for
Risk Evaluation Forum. He is currently working with a small
group of physicists, risk specialists, and others on collider risk
issues.
James has produced and conducted training programs, taught courses in
statistics, economics, and sociology at several colleges, published
articles on computer topics, and self-published cartoons and poems. His
computer programs and interface protocols for handicapped persons who
interface with a computer via a single switch were featured on the
cover
of
Communication Outlook and won first place in the Council for
Exceptional Children National Software Search, Physically Handicapped
Division.